Chapter 13: The Caseworker

The letter from the Georgia Division of Family and Children Services came three weeks later.
I knew what it was before I opened it.
Celeste's defense attorneys had been busy. They couldn't defend what she had done, so they had decided to attack the man who'd let it happen.
Me.
The motion had been filed in Florida. Copies had been sent to every agency that had ever touched Zuri's adoption.
It claimed I was an unfit, grieving, negligent single father who had abandoned a medically fragile three-year-old in the care of a woman I barely knew while I relaxed in a stateroom with my phone.
It said the "true cause" of the incident was my "failure of supervision."
It suggested that the state of Georgia might want to "review the stability of the placement."
The placement.
My daughter.
The investigation was routine, the letter said. A formality. A caseworker would visit the home within ten days.
I read the letter four times.
Then I went into Zuri's room, where she was asleep with her lanyard clutched in both hands, and I sat on the floor beside her bed for the rest of the night.
What if they were right?
I had left her.
I had said yes when Celeste offered to watch her. I had wanted one hour. One single hour.
I'd been scrolling through emails on a leather sofa while my daughter hung over the ocean.
Maybe I didn't deserve her.
The caseworker arrived on a Thursday morning.
When I opened the door, I froze.
She was older now. Her hair had gone silver at the temples. She was wearing the same kind of sensible cardigan she'd worn three years earlier, on a rainy Tuesday in March, when she'd carried an eight-month-old baby into our living room and set her on Simone's lap.
Denise Holloway.
"I asked for this case," she said quietly. "I hope that's all right."
I couldn't speak. I just stepped aside and let her in.
Zuri was in the living room building a tower out of blocks.
Denise sat down on the floor across from her.
"Hi, Zuri," she said. "My name is Miss Denise. I knew you when you were a tiny, tiny baby."
Zuri studied her very seriously.
The same way she had studied Simone, three years earlier.
"Did you know my mommy?"
Denise's eyes filled.
"I did. I knew your mommy. She grabbed you so fast when she met you, I didn't even get to say goodbye."
Zuri smiled shyly.
"She's in heaven now."
"I know, sweetheart. I'm so sorry."
Zuri put another block on her tower.
Then she said, out of nowhere, "I fell off a boat."
Denise didn't flinch.
"I heard. Can you tell me about it?"
Zuri told her.
The lady with the yellow hair. The dolphins that weren't there. The monkey bars. Holding on with both hands.
Then she held up the lanyard and showed Denise the phone.
"I said, 'Hey Siri, call Daddy.' Like Mommy's song. And he picked up."
"He did?"
"He always picks up," Zuri said matter-of-factly, stacking another block. "And then he came and got me. He was hanging upside-down. And Grandpa was holding his belt."
Denise was quiet for a long moment.
Then she asked one more question.
"Zuri, when you're scared at night, what happens?"
Zuri shrugged.
"Daddy comes."
"Every time?"
Zuri looked at her like it was the silliest question in the world.
"Every time."
Denise stayed for two hours.
She looked at Zuri's room. Her medical binder. The color-coded charts I kept for her blood sugar. The schedule on the refrigerator. The therapist's notes.
Before she left, she stood with me on the front porch.
"Ryan," she said. "I'm going to write my report tonight. And I want you to know what it's going to say."
I braced myself.
"It's going to say that a three-year-old child with a serious medical condition, who suffered a terrifying attempt on her life, knew exactly what to do in the worst moment imaginable. She knew who to call. She knew he'd answer. And she knew he'd come." Denise's voice softened. "Children don't learn that from negligent parents. They learn it from parents who show up. Over and over. Every single time."
I couldn't hold it together anymore.
I sat down on the porch steps and put my face in my hands.
Denise sat down beside me.
"You blame yourself," she said.
"I left her."
"You trusted a family member to watch her for an hour while she napped. Every parent in America does that. What happened wasn't negligence, Ryan. It was a crime. And the criminal is in jail."
May you like
She put her hand on my shoulder.
"Simone would be so proud of you," she said. "And of her."