tinge

Chapter 3

The sun came up too early.

I'd sat on that couch all night, watching Emily sleep. Every time she stirred, my heart raced. I was terrified she'd wake up screaming. That she'd think it was all still happening.

But when she finally opened her eyes, she looked at me and smiled.

A real smile. The first one in... I didn't even know how long.

"Hi, Daddy," she whispered.

"Hi, baby." I brushed the hair from her face. "How are you feeling?"

"Safe," she said simply.

That one word broke me and healed me all at once.

I made her pancakes. Her favorite. With chocolate chips and whipped cream.

We ate at the kitchen table, and for a few minutes, everything felt almost normal.

Almost.

Then the doorbell rang.

Two police officers stood on my porch. Detectives, by the look of them.

"Mr. Anderson?" The older one held up his badge. "I'm Detective Carter. This is my partner, Detective Reyes. We need to talk to you about what happened last night. And we'd like to speak with your daughter as well—with a child psychologist present, of course."

I let them in.

Over the next two hours, I told them everything.

About coming home. About what I'd seen. About what Emily had whispered to me.

Detective Carter took notes. Detective Reyes watched me with careful eyes.

"And you have no reason to doubt your daughter's claim?" Detective Reyes asked.

"None," I said firmly. "Everything she's told me... it explains things. Things I didn't want to see at the time."

Detective Carter nodded. "We spoke with your wife—Sarah—at the station. She's claiming this is all a misunderstanding. That you and your daughter are making this up. That she's a wonderful mother and you're trying to take custody away from her."

I felt anger rise in my chest. "She's lying."

"We'll find out," Detective Carter said. "In the meantime, we've ordered a full background check on Sarah Mitchell. We're also going to need to verify Emily's identity through her birth certificate and medical records."

I stood up and went to the safe in my home office. I pulled out Emily's birth certificate. My first wife's name was on it: Lisa Marie Anderson.

But there was also a legal document. A step-parent adoption paper. Sarah's name.

I stared at it. I'd signed this. I'd believed it was the right thing to do.

Detective Carter looked at the documents. "This adoption paperwork... do you know if it's legitimate?"

"I thought it was," I said. My voice was hollow. "I handled it through a lawyer Sarah recommended."

Detective Reyes made a note. "We'll look into that lawyer. If this adoption was fraudulent in any way, it changes everything."

They left a short time later, promising to keep me updated.

Emily had been playing quietly in her room while we talked. Now she came out and stood in the doorway.

"Are the police going to make her come back?" she asked quietly.

I knelt down in front of her. "No, baby. She's not coming back. I promise you. You're safe now."

She threw her arms around my neck. "I love you, Daddy."

"I love you too, Emily. More than anything in the world."

That afternoon, my lawyer called.

"James," he said. His voice was serious. "I looked into Sarah. And you need to sit down for this."

I sat.

"Her real name isn't Sarah Mitchell," he said. "It's Rachel Green. She has a criminal record. Fraud. Identity theft. And... kidnapping charges from seven years ago in another state. The case was dropped due to lack of evidence."

My blood ran cold.

"She changed her name legally five years ago," my lawyer continued. "Right around the time you two met. And the lawyer who handled the adoption? He was disbarred last year for forging legal documents."

I felt like I was going to be sick.

This woman. This stranger. She'd planned everything.

She'd targeted me. A grieving widower with a young child.

She'd inserted herself into our lives.

And she'd been planning to take my daughter from me all along.

"There's more," my lawyer said. "The police found something in your house when they did a protective sweep this morning. A hidden bag in the back of Sarah's closet. It had Emily's birth certificate, some cash, fake passports... and a one-way plane ticket to another country. For both of them."

The room spun.

She was going to run away with my daughter.

If I hadn't come home early that day. If I hadn't walked in on what was happening...

She would have been gone.

Forever.

May you like

"When was the flight?" I managed to ask.

"Tomorrow," my lawyer said softly. "She was planning to leave tomorrow."

Related Stories

Other posts